لا يجوز قراءة سورة المسد

[مقرة]

يقول أحدهم :

( وقد كنت أقرأ سورة ( تبت يدا أبي لهب ) في بعض الأحيان, فقرأت في بعض الكتب رواية عن بعض الصالحين, أنه كان يكثر من قراءة هذه السورة, فرأى رسول الله صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم في الرؤيا, وفي وجهه علائم التأثّر والعتاب, وقال له أليس هو عمي؟ يقصد أبا لهب. ومنذ ذلك الحين أمسكت عن قراءة هذه السورة إلا في الختم, إكراما لرسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم) أ.ه


فما رأيكم؟

[karima.t]

جزاك الله كل خير

[إخلاص]

يقول أحدهم :

( وقد كنت أقرأ سورة ( تبت يدا أبي لهب ) في بعض الأحيان, فقرأت في بعض الكتب رواية عن بعض الصالحين, أنه كان يكثر من قراءة هذه السورة, فرأى رسول الله صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم في الرؤيا, وفي وجهه علائم التأثّر والعتاب, وقال له أليس هو عمي؟ يقصد أبا لهب. ومنذ ذلك الحين أمسكت عن قراءة هذه السورة إلا في الختم, إكراما لرسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم) أ.ه


فما رأيكم؟

هلاّ أتيتنا بالمصدر؟؟؟
و من أين نقلته؟؟؟

[Abd El Kader]

يقول أحدهم :

( وقد كنت أقرأ سورة ( تبت يدا أبي لهب ) في بعض الأحيان, فقرأت في بعض الكتب رواية عن بعض الصالحين, أنه كان يكثر من قراءة هذه السورة, فرأى رسول الله صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم في الرؤيا, وفي وجهه علائم التأثّر والعتاب, وقال له أليس هو عمي؟ يقصد أبا لهب. ومنذ ذلك الحين أمسكت عن قراءة هذه السورة إلا في الختم, إكراما لرسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم) أ.ه


فما رأيكم؟

الحمد لله رب العالمين
لدي ملاحظات
أولا الدين لا يؤخذ من روايات الكتب عن بعض الصالحين بل لا يؤخذ من روايات الكتب عن سيد الصالحين حتى تثبت
ثانيا عمل بعض بل كل الصالحين لايؤخذ منه الدين
ثالثا هذا مما يستدل به على أن الصالح لم ير النبي صلوات ربي وسلامه عليه لأمور
أ. الرسول يحب منا أن نقرأ القرآن كله فقال مثلا بكل حرف حسنة
ب. قال تعالى لاتجد قوما يومنون بالله واليوم الآخر يوادون من حاد الله ورسوله ولو كانوا آباءهم الآيات فهل معاذ الله يخالف نبينا الآيات هذه ولقد رأينا تطبيق الصحابة للآية مع اقرب الناس فكيف بسيدهم مع عم له ؟

رابعا إكرام النبي عليه الصلاة والسلام تكون بطاعته والتمسك بسنته التي تركها فينا لا بتتبع منام صالح

[Abd El Kader]

هلاّ أتيتنا بالمصدر؟؟؟
و من أين نقلته؟؟؟

لاداعي أيتها الكريمة لذكر المصدر فقد مرة بي يوما وأنا أقرا الكتاب المصدر فانقبضت مما قرأت، لسمعة الكاتب وشهرته ومكانته

وربما ذكره هنا قد يدخل الناس في رفض الحق وتأييد الباطل لشهرة من قال به.

[يوسف أنس]

الحمد لله وبعد
اقول للاخ الفاضل كان رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم وكان الصحابة رضوان الله عليهم يتلوون كتاب الله ولم ينهى احدا منهم عن قراءة سورة المسد او اي سورة اخرى لانه كلام رب العالمين وكلام الله لا عوج فيه والله قص علينا القصص لاخذ العبرة منها.
اما ما ورد عن بعض الصالحين في شان هذه السورة الكريمة فهو مما اوقعه الشيطان فيه والقاعدة تقول ان الاحكام الشرعية تاخذ بالنص لا بالمنامات...والله اعلم

[the.edge]

countries financial freedom 2025 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/best-countries-for-financial-freedom-in-2025/)
every freelancer know nomad visas (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/what-every-freelancer-should-know-about-nomad-visas/)
succeeding self-employment (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-12-tips-for-succeeding-in-self-employment/)
smart saving (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-10-smart-saving-that-work/)
beginner digital nomads 2026 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/beginners-guide-to-digital-nomads-in-2026/)
succeeding side hustles (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-5-tips-for-succeeding-in-side-hustles/)
business models based crypto trading (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-12-business-models-based-on-crypto-trading/)
beginner online education 2024 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/beginners-guide-to-online-education-in-2024/)
succeeding halal investing (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-20-tips-for-succeeding-in-halal-investing/)
turn digital nomads full-time career (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/how-to-turn-digital-nomads-into-a-full-time-career/)
avoid mistakes when doing home (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/avoid-these-mistakes-when-doing-work-from-home/)
succeeding content creation (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-15-tips-for-succeeding-in-content-creation/)
things tells online (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/things-no-one-tells-you-about-online-jobs/)
start smart saving 2025 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/how-to-start-smart-saving-in-2025/)
crypto trading booming right (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/why-crypto-trading-is-booming-right-now/)
dropshipping booming right (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/why-dropshipping-is-booming-right-now/)
stock market change life 2024 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/how-stock-market-can-change-your-life-in-2024/)
ways money affiliate marketing (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-20-ways-to-make-money-with-affiliate-marketing/)
online education start today (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-10-online-education-you-can-start-today/)
succeeding print demand (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-20-tips-for-succeeding-in-print-on-demand/)
ways money content creation (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-5-ways-to-make-money-with-content-creation/)
ways money freelancing (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-12-ways-to-make-money-with-freelancing/)
succeeding stock market (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-10-tips-for-succeeding-in-stock-market/)
freelancing start today (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-5-freelancing-you-can-start-today/)
succeeding print demand (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-7-tips-for-succeeding-in-print-on-demand/)
online business legality (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-10-online-business-legality-that-work/)
countries supporting side hustles 2025 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/best-countries-supporting-side-hustles-in-2025/)
beginner crypto trading 2025 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/beginners-guide-to-crypto-trading-in-2025/)
ways money content creation (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-15-ways-to-make-money-with-content-creation/)
ways money financial freedom (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-5-ways-to-make-money-with-financial-freedom/)
countries time freedom 2025 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/best-countries-for-time-freedom-in-2025/)
turn self-employment full-time career (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/how-to-turn-self-employment-into-a-full-time-career/)
steps achieve online coaching without quitting (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/steps-to-achieve-online-coaching-without-quitting-your-job/)
succeeding nomad visas (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-10-tips-for-succeeding-in-nomad-visas/)
ways money remote (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-7-ways-to-make-money-with-remote-work/)
tools start financial freedom (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/best-tools-to-start-your-financial-freedom/)
remote related dropshipping (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-7-remote-jobs-related-to-dropshipping/)
ways money nomad visas (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-7-ways-to-make-money-with-nomad-visas/)
business automation (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-10-business-automation-that-work/)
business models based budgeting (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-5-business-models-based-on-budgeting/)
ways money crypto trading (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-20-ways-to-make-money-with-crypto-trading/)
succeeding budgeting (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-12-tips-for-succeeding-in-budgeting/)
turn freelancing full-time career (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/how-to-turn-freelancing-into-a-full-time-career/)
experts say self-employment 2026 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/what-experts-say-about-self-employment-in-2026/)
remote related online coaching (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-20-remote-jobs-related-to-online-coaching/)
remote related print demand (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-12-remote-jobs-related-to-print-on-demand/)
ways money crypto trading (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-12-ways-to-make-money-with-crypto-trading/)
ways money online (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-12-ways-to-make-money-with-online-jobs/)
online booming right (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/why-online-jobs-is-booming-right-now/)
ways money nomad visas (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-15-ways-to-make-money-with-nomad-visas/)
succeeding financial freedom (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-7-tips-for-succeeding-in-financial-freedom/)
countries low taxes crypto investment (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/countries-with-low-taxes-for-crypto-investment/)
countries supporting stock market 2025 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/best-countries-supporting-stock-market-in-2025/)
succeeding online education (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-5-tips-for-succeeding-in-online-education/)
business models based dropshipping (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-20-business-models-based-on-dropshipping/)
business models based nomad visas (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-10-business-models-based-on-nomad-visas/)
remote related digital nomads (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-15-remote-jobs-related-to-digital-nomads/)
things tells passive income (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/things-no-one-tells-you-about-passive-income/)
remote related online education (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-5-remote-jobs-related-to-online-education/)
ways money freelancing (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-15-ways-to-make-money-with-freelancing/)
smart strategies dropshipping success (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/smart-strategies-for-dropshipping-success/)
remote related passive income (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-12-remote-jobs-related-to-passive-income/)
dropshipping future employment (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/why-dropshipping-is-the-future-of-employment/)
succeeding digital products (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-10-tips-for-succeeding-in-digital-products/)
online business legality start today (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-10-online-business-legality-you-can-start-today/)
beginner financial freedom 2026 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/beginners-guide-to-financial-freedom-in-2026/)
remote related content creation (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-20-remote-jobs-related-to-content-creation/)
countries side hustles 2025 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/best-countries-for-side-hustles-in-2025/)
beginner content creation 2024 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/beginners-guide-to-content-creation-in-2024/)
avoid mistakes when doing dropshipping (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/avoid-these-mistakes-when-doing-dropshipping/)
business models based budgeting (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-15-business-models-based-on-budgeting/)
business models based business (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-12-business-models-based-on-ai-in-business/)
countries supporting budgeting 2025 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/best-countries-supporting-budgeting-in-2025/)
tools start tax savings (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/best-tools-to-start-your-tax-savings/)
online start today (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-5-online-jobs-you-can-start-today/)
succeeding digital nomads (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-15-tips-for-succeeding-in-digital-nomads/)
financial freedom change life 2025 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/how-financial-freedom-can-change-your-life-in-2025/)
work-from-home start today (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-15-work-from-home-jobs-you-can-start-today/)
online business legality start today (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-12-online-business-legality-you-can-start-today/)
passive income change life 2026 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/how-passive-income-can-change-your-life-in-2026/)
ways money budgeting (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-7-ways-to-make-money-with-budgeting/)
beginner business 2026 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/beginners-guide-to-ai-in-business-in-2026/)
start remote 2025 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/how-to-start-remote-work-in-2025/)
beginner passive income 2026 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/beginners-guide-to-passive-income-in-2026/)
experts say print demand 2024 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/what-experts-say-about-print-on-demand-in-2024/)
financial freedom future employment (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/why-financial-freedom-is-the-future-of-employment/)
succeeding content creation (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-12-tips-for-succeeding-in-content-creation/)
online coaching start today (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-12-online-coaching-you-can-start-today/)
crypto investment start today (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-5-crypto-investment-you-can-start-today/)
legal ways start freelancing home (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/legal-ways-to-start-freelancing-from-home/)
countries digital nomads 2025 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/best-countries-for-digital-nomads-in-2025/)
succeeding online education (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-20-tips-for-succeeding-in-online-education/)
experts say dropshipping 2026 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/what-experts-say-about-dropshipping-in-2026/)
countries low taxes tax savings (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/countries-with-low-taxes-for-tax-savings/)
steps achieve gig economy without quitting (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/steps-to-achieve-gig-economy-without-quitting-your-job/)
online education start today (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-7-online-education-you-can-start-today/)
beginner affiliate marketing 2025 (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/beginners-guide-to-affiliate-marketing-in-2025/)
business models based passive income (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-12-business-models-based-on-passive-income/)
tools need crypto trading (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-tools-you-need-for-crypto-trading/)
nomad visas start today (https://jobs.sahla-dz.com/top-5-nomad-visas-you-can-start-today/)